Jessica held onto both of Sarah's arms as Dustin got into position to deflower her in front of everybody. Tara scooted down and helped pull one of Sarah's legs apart, which was just enough to allow Dustin to slip in.
"AAAAUGH!" Sarah screamed, jerking enough for my dick to pop out of her mouth and onto her face. "STTTTOP ITT!!!" Jessica quickly put her hands over Sarah's mouth, muffling her screams.
"Just take it you stupid bitch, there is nothing you can do about it now," Jessica said matter-of-factly as Dustin started to thrust. "How tight is she?" Jessica asked.
"Mmm she feels so good," Dustin said in ecstacy as I moved his hips faster and faster, now grabbing onto her legs and wrapping them around him. He laid his head on Sarah's big breasts and got into a steady flow. Each thrust was matched with a groan coming from Sarah's muffled mouth.
Becky, at this point, was nothing more than a toy herself. Ryan was slamming into her from behind, smacking her ass with his midsection each time he pushed in. He also had a tight grip on her hair and was keeping her steady as she continued to suck Austin's dick.
Tara went back to kneel down beside Becky, gently grabbing ahold of her swinging tits as her torture continued. "Not so tough anymore, are you honey?" She spoke as the worst night of Becky's life ensued. "Give it to her extra hard for me boys. I want her to be sore for days after this. Maybe she'll think twice about fucking with our night next time."
Tara continued to rub it in, speaking into Becky's ear now. "Mmmm yeah how does her mouth feel Austin?" Tara said, getting no reply from the silent wrestler, who was still battling his concious a bit. Tara grabbed her own piece of Becky's long hair and ordered her to look up. "You look at Austin when you're sucking his cock, bitch!"
Ryan was relentlessly pounding Becky doggy-style, but he and Tara continued to manipulate her hair to give Austin some great head. Tara reached around and started to grab Austin's ass now, complimenting his groove. "Great job, baby, give it to her! That mouth belongs to you," she began to almost moan before talking back at Becky. "Don't you fucking look away bitch, look him in the eyes. Little prude bitch, you're nothing. How does it feel to get used like this, huh? You try and tell anyone and I'll have these two riding you every night until graduation!"
Seemingly out of nowhere, a loud moan came from Austin's mouth. "Ooh shhhittt," he groaned as he clinched onto Becky's head and quickly shoved his dick in a little deeper.
Becky's groans said it all. To the absolute delight of Tara, Austin had just exploded. "No way!" Tara exclaimed. "Did you just cum in her mouth!?!?!?"
Austin closed his eyes tightly as he let out everything he had into Becky's mouth before slowly pulling out, which made a good amount of cum spill out of her lips and she looked to the ground, almost nauseous. Ryan didn't let up from behind her but there was still a good amount of silence, asside from her crying and spitting out cum, and Sarah's groans underneath Dustin.
Tara looked over at the rest of us with her mouth agape with a genuinely surprised and extremely pleased face. "Is she that good at giving blowjobs?" She teased Austin, taunting Becky as she did. "Wow you really are a slut. Who just lets a guy cum in her mouth like that without warning, you've never even been on one date with him!"
Austin, thinking even more clearly now stumbled over to his clothes and sat down, staring off into space a bit thinking about what just happened. Sure, I felt a little bad seeing it happen, but it was hard to focus on how bad I felt with Sarah still getting fucked silly in front of me.
The site of Sarah getting taken by Dustin was extremely erotic. Her arms were pinned straight above her head by Jessica, and he had started to lean up a bit, allowing her big tits to bounce. Up and down, up and down, up and down they went. I just watched in awe, thinking of how I had been satisfied to see just a little of her cleavage before and now I was watching her bare body get ravaged...and I could step in at anytime and do whatever I wanted.
Every once in a while, I'd get a handful of Sarah's boob as I slowly stroked to the site of her first sexual experience. I was patiently waiting turn, but my trance was interrupted by Tara and Ryan walking a naked Becky over towards us.
I looked up and admired her body as they forced her to walk over before dropping her to her knees. "Stephen, come take Becky for a bit!" Tara offered. Ryan, apparently wanting a piece of both girls, walked up and knelt down in front of Sarah's face, almost like he was entitled to her mouth, which in a way he almost was since nobody was stopping him.
As I stood up and walked around Sarah's body, Tara unceremoniously pushed Becky over Sarah so their belly's touched. Dustin had no problem continuing and even welcomed the site of another naked female within grabbing distance.
My heart started going faster again as I knelt behind Becky. It was almost unreal. She was exausted and it took nothing for me to push into her. It was the first time I had felt the inside of a vagina for months, so I didn't want to take it too fast.
Becky let out a groan as the second dick of the night pushed into her from behind. "She's still got plenty left," taunted Tara once more. "Don't take it easy on her," she flirted.
I cherished the feeling, and the site of Becky's body. Ryan was already forcing Sarah to suck him and for the first time all night, the bad girls could just hang out and watch as the two victims took their fuckings.
I took every liberty I could with Becky's firm ass as I took her from behind. I smacked it, I grabbed it, I stared at it for a while. She had worked so hard, running very morning so her body could be well fit for the upcoming basketball and soccer season, and now that figure was mine, to do with what I wanted.
Austin, now dressed and still in a daze came over and sat next to Jessica and Tara as the three watched on. It was a pretty quiet show for a while, until it was time for the next guy to release.
This one had a little more warning. Ryan called over to the girls, speaking for the first time in quite a while. "Hey girls hold her steady, I'm gonna cum."
Ryan slipped his dick out of Sarah's mouth, which caused her eyes to grow wide, watching and wondering what his plans could be. As the girls held her hair down, he knelt over her breasts, rubbing and slapping his dick on them.
"Mmm good choice!" Jessica shouted as he began frantically jerking his dick against her chest, rubbing both tits against his head and shaft as he did so. "Yeah Ryan!" Jessica cheered. "Get it baby!"
Tara chimed in with some words of her own as he leaned over a little more and even started thrusting his hips as he stroked against her chest. "Those big boobies are gonna be covered!" Tara shouted in an almost childish way. "Get ready boobies here it comes!"
Ryan's eyes rolled back in his head as he began to cum all over Sarah's DDs. Dustin and I both temporarily slowed oru thrustng to watch and Sarah's eyes filled up with tears as she watched felt the sensation of warm cum for the first time.
Drops of semen ran all over her great clevage down to her erect nipples. Sarah freed her hands in time to rub most of it off of herself as Ryan stood up victoriously, but the site of her wiping off her breasts was a welcome one for me.
"Hey man," Dustin looked over and said to me in the chaos. "Wanna trade?"
As fun as it was to take Becky, I couldn't pass up the opportunity to fuck two girls in one night, and I was getting close to cumming myself. It didn't take much work as Dustin dragged Becky back off of Sarah and I took his position.
Sarah had just finished wiping her hands in the grass to dry them off when I kneeled down, placing my dick against her entry-way. "Wait, pleeease!" She continued to beg as she leaned up to try and push me away.
Once again, her sweet eyes made contact with mine as she struggled, before inevitably getting grabbed again by Tara and Jessica, who slammed her back down on her back. I didn't have much trouble slipping myself inside and away I went, fucking the helpless girl as her arms were once again pinned.
There was somthing intimate about it this time, as I took Sarah by myself now, with only the girls helping me hold her down. I had free range. Grabbing her tits, cupping her ass, whatever I wanted to do as I pushed into her.
Dustin didn't last long with Becky's tight body. Already edging himself, he decided not to slow up at all as he entered her from behind, the third guy to take her in that position on the night.
Her face layed just inches away from Sarah's torso as she stared to the side, taking Dustin's every thrust.
Dustin may have been kind of a bonehead in the classroom, but he was smart enough not to cum in her. Once he got close, he quietly pulled out and Becky laid silently as she felt the boy stroke his dick against her ass cheeks.
Dustin took one last up at Sarah, who he had deflowered earlier, before letting himself release. It was the quiest orgasm of the night. He moaned a little and she groaned a little, but everyone else just watched as he came all over her round white ass.
Becky's athletic body laid still as he got up, watching his cum roll off her ass cheeks, but at this point she knew it was better to just lay there and wait for us to leave them.
After a good four or five minutes of fucking Sarah as everyone else just gathered around watching, I was ready to finish up. I thought it would only be appropriate to let our female accomplices decide on which part of Sarah's body would get the last of what us guys had left to offer. "Where do you want it, girls?"
Jessica leaned over Sarah's body, teasing me once more as she poured out of her tank top. She ran her finger all over Sarah's body, even playfully pinching both nipples as she decided. A smile came over her as she leaned back and pulled Sarah's hair out of her face. "I think she needs it right here."
Tara motioned for the boys to hold Sarah, and they did so as I crawled up her body, letting my dick wander all over before straddling her tits and beginning to stroke. Sarah stared at me silently and humiliatingly as tears began to fall down her face again.
The mix of her ultimate humiliation and the pleasure Jessica got from watching in anticipation made my heart bump. I leaned down and began to rub my edging cock on Sarah's face, focusing on the outside of her lips, which were pursed. As if I needed any extra motivation to let loose, Jessica leaned over and gave me a passionate kiss as she held Sarah's face still. "Don't get any of it on me," she teased. "She deserves it all."
Tara began to rub my chest and ran her fingers down to past my belly button as I stroked. "I can take it from here, Stephen." She purred. "Just enjoy it."
Tara grasped my dick and stroked fast and hard, keeping it locked on Sarah's face as she smacked the it over and over and her cheeks and lips. I used my placed my free hands on Sarah's shoulders as I prepared to release.
"Here it comes." I moaned, signaling for Jessica to keep a tight grip on Sarah's head so she can't jerk it away. Tara kicked it up a notch with the hand job and I felt my orgasm hit.
Like an artist, Tara painted Sarah's face with my cum, keeping a steady stroke as she did so. It was the most pleasurable orgasm I ever had as I fully released onto Sarah's beautiful, innocent face.
"Mmm, happy homecoming Sarah!" Jessica mocked as I slowly got up, regret starting to seep in. Both victims laid quietly on the ground as the rest of us got up and got our things.
Before leaving, Tara walked up and grabbed Becky's hair yet again, yanking it up so she could make eye contact. "Remember what I said. Tell anyone and you're both getting it ten times worse."
All the guys in the group were silent as we made our way back to our cars. The girls didn't let up, talking about the attack and doing impressions of the two victims.
"So you're just gonna raaape mee?" Tara laughed, giving Ryan a playful punch. "Stop it, you're huuurting her!" Jessica cackled.
To this day I can't explain the evil I saw in Tara and Jessica that night. I never went out with their group again, but always wondered if they had claimed other victims without me.
Sarah and Becky never said a word, at least not to anyone with authority, although I still check over my shoulder and panic when I hear someone at the door. They never confronted me either, making any classes with either of them awkward.
Months later, in senior seminar class, Becky and I were randomly paired up for a partner project. We silently worked together throughout the class period, keeping all chatter to a minimum. As she stared down at her paper, I spotted Jessica walking past us to go to the bathroom. She gave me an evil smile mimed a sexual moaning "oh" face as she walked past, obviously alluding to the two of us working together. I scooted a little further away from Becky and put my notebook in my lap to save her the embarrassment of noticing my growing erection.
*NOTE: Once again, this is a completely fictional story and I do not condone sexual violence of any kind. If you liked the story, let me know your favorite part, favorite characters, or something you would have like to see happen. I might do another story soon!*